It was 50 years agoin 1961when doreen kimura published two articles describing how dichotic digit testing could be used to help describe central auditory processing. She discovered a rightear advantage rea for linguistic stimuli, which is associated empirically with lefthemisphere language representation kimura, 1961a, kimura, 1961b. Life experience and the asymmetry of the human auditory. Studdert kennedy, 1966 the journal of acoustical society of america, 1970, 48, 579 594. Dichotic listening dl tests are among the most frequently included in batteries for the diagnosis of auditory processing disorders apd in children. A total of 30 participants completed a dichoticlistening task including three workingmemory load conditions, each consisting of trials of 3, 4, and. The ubiquitous rightear advantage rea for verbal material was accepted as a concomitant of leftsided language lateralization and preferential conduction of rightear messages to the left hemisphere. In this paper doreen kimura gives a personal history of the rightear. The term rightear effect or rightear advantage can be used to. The pioneering work of doreen kimura and brenda milner, at the montreal neurological institute, set the stage for two decades of research on the apparent right ear advantage for linguistic processing and the apparent left ear advantage for pitch and melody processing.
The advantage of the crossed pathway had not previously been detected because speech is not usually presented in a way which promotes competition between ears. Reversely, a leftear advantage is thought to indicate atypical righthemispheric dominance. The right ear advantage rea a brief history of dl research doreen kimura, 1961 d. Kimura, 2011, the primary connections are the crossed pathways. The doreen kimura structural model of dichotic listening. The role of working memory in dichoticlistening studies. The ubiquitous rightear advantage rea for verbal material was accepted as a concomitant of leftsided language lateralization and preferential conduction of rightear. The discovery of the right ear advantage in 1961 by doreen kimura to dichotic presentations of phonetic stimuli paved the way for new studies of how speech perception and related language processes are lateralized in the human brain. About 10 years later, doreen kimura 1961a, 1961b modified the paradigm and used spoken digits, which were presented simultaneously via headphones, one to each ear, to. As a further control for the effects of lefthemisphere. That association opened up the prospect of revealing cerebral structure in intact humans with noninvasive methodologies. Doreen kimura found that the processing for backward speech was the same as normal speech.
In the early 1960s, doreen kimura used dichotic listening tests to draw conclusions about lateral asymmetry of auditory processing in the brain. This is called the right ear advantage because auditory connections are greatest on the contralateral side of the brain this theory is attributed to left handedness and left handed males. Scientific american is the essential guide to the most aweinspiring advances in science and technology, explaining how they change our understanding of the world and shape our lives. Because each ear has greater neural representation in the opposite cerebral hemisphere, the predominance of the left hemispere for speech is reflected in superior recognition for words arriving at the right ear. Doreen kimura adapted the tests over 50 years ago, which. The model proposes that the rightear advantageleftear disadvantage in dichotic listening is based on the essentially hardwired connections among the two ears, the crossed and uncrossed auditory pathways, the specialization of the left hemisphere for linguistic processing. A workingmemory procedure was actually used in the pioneering dichoticlistening studies by doreen kimura in 1960, a fact that was forgotten in later dichoticlistening studies, exclusively focusing on the perceptual. If you notice any inaccuracies, please sign in and mark papers as correct or incorrect matches.
This was a surprising finding since most theories of hemisphere asymmetry. Dit verschijnsel heet ook wel rechteroorvoordeel engels. In the early 60s, doreen kimura reported that dichotic verbal stimuli specifically spoken numerals presented to a participant produced a right ear advantage rea. Fifty years of dichotic listening research still going. This method was subsequently used for assessing cerebral lateralisation in neuropsychological patients, and a theory was developed that linked the right ear advantage to cerebral. Doreen kimura 1961a, 1961b, been linked to hemispheric asymmetry for speech and. Kimuras experiments showed a right ear advantage rea only in the dichotic listening experiment, but not in the monotic listening experiment. She attributed the rightear advantage to the localization of speech and language processing in the socalled dominant left hemisphere of the cerebral cortex. Words from right ear are typically repeated right ear advantage bc right ear lhlanguage. The rightear effect going strong after fifty years. In the case where speech is represented in the right hemisphere. If you identify any major omissions or other inaccuracies in the publication list, please let us know.
Functional asymmetry of the brain in dichotic listening. Dichotic listening originally was a means of studying attention. The focus is on the early groundbreaking papers, describing how she did the first dichotic. A primer on dichotic listening as a paradigm for the. It was 50 years agoin 1961when doreen kimura published two articles. A finding of atypical left ear advantage lea for speechrelated stimuli is often taken by clinical. Kimura 1967 explains the rea for verbal stimulus by the fact that the right ear is connected to the language dominant left hemisphere of the brain and the left ear.
Doreen kimura 1967 asserted that a dichotic signal i. The research conducted was trying to examine if indeed the right ear advantage to listening can be recreated. Kimura was finishing her final year of high school via correspondence while teaching in a oneroom schoolhouse in northern manitoba when she applied to and won an entrance scholarship to mcgill university in montreal. The listen mode the beginnings of the dichotic listening technique can be traced back to the 1950s and donald broadbent, who was interested in testing auditory attention abilities in air traffic controllers. Doreen kimura 193320 was a graduate student in the neuropsychology laboratory of brenda milner at the montreal neurological institute in the early 1960s. Dichotic listening can also be used to test the hemispheric asymmetry of language processing. A left ear advantage lea for music and different nonspeech sounds has also been described. That association opened up the prospect of revealing cerebral structure in intact. Dichotic listening usually produces a right ear advantage recalling. Kimura 1967 explains the rea for verbal stimulus by the fact that the right ear is connected to the language dominant left hemisphere of the brain and the left ear to the right hemisphere through the contralateral pathways. In everyday speech the same material arrives at the two ears. Example, rather than presenting pa andka sounds to the left and right ear respectively. By contrast, the left ear has the advantage with a dichotic test involving emotionally intoned sentences.
Doreen kimura the leftear superiority is not related to the site of the damage in the rightdominant group. We are testing a new system for linking publications to authors. For example, whereas women perform better than men in both verbal memory recalling words from lists. She discovered a rightear advantage rea for linguistic stimuli, which is associated empirically with lefthemisphere language representation kimura, 1961a, 1961b. I there and then tested a small number of righthanded normal subjects and found a significant rightear. Kimura went on to earn bachelors, masters, and doctoral in 1961 degrees from mcgill. In the early 60s, doreen kimura reported that dichotic verbal stimuli specifically spoken numerals presented to a participant produced a right ear advantage. This rightear advantage rea, following the initial description and validation of the phenomenon by doreen kimura kimura, 1961a, 1961b, is nowadays widely interpreted to re. Kimura 1967 explains the rea for verbal stimulus by the fact that the right ear is connected to the language dominant left hemisphere of the brain and the left ear to the right. One of the effects of a rightside surge, caused by testosterone, is that men are less attuned to words spoken in their left ear than those in their right. Introduced by doreen kimura 1970 two competing messages are presented simultaneously per ear and subject tries to report both messages. Dichotic listening wikimili, the free encyclopedia. Kimura and milner recorded their own dichotic digits test with the aim of applying it to patients with temporal lobe epilepsy.
Capitalizing on the original kimura 1961a, 1961b studies, we hypothesized that an increase in workingmemory load leads to an amplified rightear advantage rea in the dichoticlistening task. Doreen kimura was the first to apply the dichotic listening method to neuropsychology. Half a century ago doreen kimura parlayed the dichotic method into a noninvasive indicator of lateralized cerebral language representation. The discovery of the rightear advantage in dichotic listening was one such breakthrough. Left ear advantage in speechrelated dichotic listening is. The sounds or presentations were then reversed to the collateral ears. Opinion article life experience and the asymmetry of the. Doreen kimura 193320 was a graduate student in the neuropsychology laboratory of.
It is important to keep in mind that some of the average sex differences in cognition vary from slight to quite large and that men and women overlap enormously on many cognitive tests that show average differences. It is now almost 60 years since doreen kimura first described the asymmetries of the human auditory system has. Hormones factors in fetus gender and child future development. In this paper doreen kimura gives a personal history of the rightear effect in dichotic listening. We present data related to the role of working memory in dichoticlistening studies of speech lateralization using consonantvowel syllable stimuli. More than half a century ago doreen kimura studied ear laterality by using dichotic tests. Doreen kimuras research works simon fraser university. Kimura observed that most subjects who were shown by the wada tests to have a left hemisphere language dominance reported the sound that they heard from their right ear. That association opened up the prospect of revealing cerebral. This year celebrates 50 years of research in auditory laterality and hemispheric asymmetry, using a dichotic listening approach. The average behaviour of this virtual beamformer supported the lateralization of auditory attention and the rightear advantage 30. There are ascending auditory pathways that connect both ears to both the left and right auditory cortices acs. Ss and shortlong sl resulting in an average rightear advantage rea, while the fourth condition, longshort ls, resulted in an average leftear advantage lea. Mismatch negativity and ear laterality in alzheimers.
174 446 496 961 613 1427 1516 132 728 587 1081 171 235 1134 1216 551 975 1057 722 1243 944 303 517 310 163 942 865 39